Image

Comparison of Patella Plating Versus Tension Band Wiring for the Treatment of Unstable Patellar Fractures

Comparison of Patella Plating Versus Tension Band Wiring for the Treatment of Unstable Patellar Fractures

Recruiting
18 years and older
All
Phase N/A

Powered by AI

Overview

This study aims to compare the efficacy and safety of patella anatomical locking plate fixation versus tension band wiring in the treatment of patellar fractures.

Description

Patellar fractures are a common injury that can cause significant pain and disability. Conventional treatment options frequently include tension band wiring (TBW) with or without axial K-Wires or through cannulated screws. However, tension band wiring does have its issues, including implant prominence and frequent reoperation rates, especially for comminuted patella fractures.

More recently, plate fixation has become increasingly more prevalent in the past decade. Initially, this began with small fragment or mini-fragment plates; which progressed to mesh locking plates and now, anatomical locking patella plates. Biomechanical studies have shown greater loads to failure, less fracture gapping or fracture displacement with locking plate fixation compared to TBW. Its low profile construct and round edges may be more tolerable to patients and less prominent than TBW. Furthermore, another possible advantage of plate fixation is the avoidance of quadricep and patellar tendon insertion scarring, as they do not need to be dissected or passed through for fixation as in TBW. This is the first randomized controlled trial comparing anatomical locking plate fixation and conventional tension band wiring for patella fractures to be performed. This study aims to compare the efficacy and safety of these two methods in the treatment of patellar fractures.

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Aged 18 years or older
  • Diagnosed with an isolated closed injury, displaced, unstable fracture with displacement >2mm (AO/OTA Classification 34-B and C with surgical indication)
  • Able to give consent

Exclusion Criteria:

  • History of previous knee surgery
  • Poly trauma,
  • Ongoing malignancy
  • Pre-existing severe knee osteoarthritis (>KL stage 4)
  • Stroke
  • Other neurological conditions/injuries to the lower limb
  • Unfit for surgical anaesthesia
  • Non-ambulatory
  • Unable to consent or follow commands

Study details
    Patella Fracture

NCT06981039

The University of Hong Kong

15 October 2025

Step 1 Get in touch with the nearest study center
We have submitted the contact information you provided to the research team at {{SITE_NAME}}. A copy of the message has been sent to your email for your records.
Would you like to be notified about other trials? Sign up for Patient Notification Services.
Sign up

Send a message

Enter your contact details to connect with study team

Investigator Avatar

Primary Contact

  Other languages supported:

First name*
Last name*
Email*
Phone number*
Other language

FAQs

Learn more about clinical trials

What is a clinical trial?

A clinical trial is a study designed to test specific interventions or treatments' effectiveness and safety, paving the way for new, innovative healthcare solutions.

Why should I take part in a clinical trial?

Participating in a clinical trial provides early access to potentially effective treatments and directly contributes to the healthcare advancements that benefit us all.

How long does a clinical trial take place?

The duration of clinical trials varies. Some trials last weeks, some years, depending on the phase and intention of the trial.

Do I get compensated for taking part in clinical trials?

Compensation varies per trial. Some offer payment or reimbursement for time and travel, while others may not.

How safe are clinical trials?

Clinical trials follow strict ethical guidelines and protocols to safeguard participants' health. They are closely monitored and safety reviewed regularly.
Add a private note
  • abc Select a piece of text.
  • Add notes visible only to you.
  • Send it to people through a passcode protected link.