Overview
This is a multi-site, multi-visit feasibility RCT of music therapy (MT) among adolescent and adult patients (aged 14 and older) with sickle cell disease (SCD).
Subjects will be randomized into one of three groups, either (1) 6 visits of in- person MT (InMT:); (2) 1 visit of in-person MT and 5 visits of virtual MT (HybMT); or (3) 1 visit of in-person health education and 5 visits of virtual health education (HybHE).
Cohorts of 15 participants (10 at site 1 and 5 site 2) will be recruited each quarter for 6 quarters to reach 90 participants. Cohorts will maintain a semi-structured recruitment, consenting, assessment, and intervention schedule.
The primary objective of the study is to examine the feasibility of study. This is defined by 6 metrics: (1) completeness of data collection, (2) participant screening, (3) participant recruitment, (4) participant retention, (5) Individual attendance and (6) Home practice. A final determination of "feasibility" for the study will be met if any 4 of the 6 metrics described above are met.
This study will also include a secondary objective of conducting qualitative interviews to assess feasibility of implementation.
Description
The objectives of this study are to (1) conduct a feasibility randomized control trial (RCT), to examine the data collection processes, and intervention (in-person music therapy [InMT], hybrid MT [HybMT], and hybrid health education [HybHE]) implementation overall and across 2 sites (University Hospitals/Case Western Reserve University [site 1] and Prisma Health/University of South Carolina [site 2]); and (2) evaluate the implementation of the InMT, HybMT, and HybHE interventions using both quantitative data (study records, stakeholder surveys) and qualitative data (interviews).
Three wellbeing programs for individuals with SCD will be compared: (1) InMT, (2) HybMT, and (3) HybHE. Each intervention includes 6 sessions. The treatment period for each group will be 6 to 8 weeks. Each weekly session will last up to one hour in all arms of the study. MT sessions in the InMT and HybMT arms will include the topics of SCD education and MT rationale, breathing exercises, relaxation, imagery, music making, and review and creation of a coping plan for future challenges. The HybHE group will use an adapted version of Project Patients Empowered and Educated Providers (PEEP). Covered topics include: science of SCD, identifying barriers in the Emergency Department, tools for navigating the healthcare system, healthcare based communication, and review and planning for future challenges.
Semi-structured qualitative interview topics will focus on participants' perceptions of the interventions, perceived benefits and burdens of the interventions, and other barriers and facilitators to in-person and hybrid delivery.
Eligibility
Inclusion Criteria:
- Be aged 14 years or older;
- Have a diagnosis of SCD present in their electronic health record (EHR);
- Meet Analgesic, Anesthetic, and Addiction Clinical Trial Translations Innovations Opportunities and Networks-American Pain Society Pain Taxonomy (AAPT) criteria for chronic SCD pain which includes:
(3a) A diagnosis of SCD confirmed by laboratory testing (present in EHR per eligibility criteria 2) (3b) Reports of ongoing pain present on most days over the past 6 months either in a single location or in multiple locations (to be obtained at screening) (3c) Displaying at least one of the following signs on clinical exam (to be obtained from providers' clinical notes in the EHR
- Palpation of the region of reported pain elicits focal pain or tenderness;
- Movement of the region of reported pain elicits focal pain;
- Decreased range of motion or weakness in the region of reported pain;
- Evidence of skin ulcer in the region of reported pain;
- Evidence of hepatobiliary or splenic imaging abnormalities (e.g., splenic infarct, chronic pancreatitis) consistent with the region of reported pain; or
- Evidence of imaging abnormalities consistent with bone infarction or avascular necrosis in the region of reported; (3d) There is no other diagnosis that better explains the signs and symptoms (to be obtained from providers following referral and pre-screening) (4) Be able to speak and understand English; (5) Have an email address and access to mobile device with a functioning data plan (6) Reporting that pain interfered with daily activities at least 1-2 days in the past week.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Have a significant visual, hearing, or cognitive impairment
- Have previously participated in the MUSIQOLS single-site pilot study at University Hospitals in 2018
- Are currently engaging in mind-body therapies under the supervision of a healthcare professional specifically for pain management
- Have a planned major medical event in the next 14 weeks such as (but not limited to) childbirth, orthopedic surgery, gene therapy, or stem cell transplant (These criteria do not include blood transfusions, exchange transfusions, or other pharmacologic pain treatment).
Qualitative interviews will be conducted with 24 participants who received the interventions (with equal numbers across the InMT, HybMT and HybHE groups). Participants will be purposively sampled to include both sexes, younger and older participants, and distribution across sites in proportion to recruitment.
Stakeholder surveys and qualitative interviews will be conducted among 20 relevant staff stakeholders (10 per site), including healthcare providers & staff, music therapists and HybHE interventionists.