Overview
The primary purpose of this study is to conduct a clinical trial to test a prototype device for feasibility and not health outcomes. To do this, the investigators will evaluate the performance of commercially available inertial measurement unit sensors incorporated into an existing ankle brace ("sXAB") by TayCo Brace, Inc. We will compare the gait metrics calculated from the sensors incorporated into the brace with gold-standard equipment that is used in research and clinical settings to determine whether the sXAB performs adequately in terms of measurement or technical feasibility prior to further clinical evaluation. The sensors in the ankle brace will be validated in the lab, first on healthy subjects walking in standard tennis shoes/sneakers (protocol 1), and secondarily in the lab on healthy subjects wearing combat boots performing walking, running, jumping, and stair climbing (protocol 2). These movements were selected because they simulate key movements performed during operational activities. Protocol 1 will take place first, then aspects of the sXAB will be evaluated and implemented, then protocol 2 will take place. Participants completing protocol 1 are eligible to complete protocol 2. The study includes two cohorts of participants completing different functional tasks. All participants experience both conditions: with an ankle brace and without an ankle brace. Comparisons are made within-subject between brace and no-brace conditions. It is hypothesized that the sensor-enabled ankle brace will measure gait metrics with a high degree of accuracy (within 5%) when compared against the gold-standard lab equipment (i.e., motion capture and research-grade inertial measurement units).
Description
This study is funded by a grant from the United States Air Force awarded to TayCo Brace, Inc. The required research partner, Indiana University (Principal Investigator Allison Gruber, PhD), holds the subaward. All human subjects activities are taking place at the Indiana University Bloomington (IUB) campus. Potential participants for study protocols 1 and 2 will be recruited from the community and the IUB campus. Paper flyers will be posted on campus and the surrounding commercial areas. Electronic flyers will be posted in the IUB classifies, on the iConnect website, and on social media. Potential participants will either contact the research team to complete the initial screening or respond to the flyer via a QR code that takes them directly to the online version of the screening form. The screening form asks yes/no questions from the Physical Activity Readiness Questionnaire (PARQ+) and additional questions about the individuals health history, musculoskeletal injury history, and current physical activity levels. After initial screening to determine eligibility, provisionally eligible participants will come to the laboratory on the IUB campus to complete enrollment and study procedures.
During visit 1 for study protocols 1 and 2, participants will read the informed consent document and, after all questions have been answered, sign the informed consent document if they agree to participate in the study. Next, participants will complete a health history questionnaire which repeats the PARQ+ questions and additional health history questions presented in the initial screening to confirm eligibility. Foot length measurements and additional surveys (i.e., the Identification of Functional Ankle Instability (IDFAI) and International Physical Activity Questionnaire - Short Form (IPAQ)) will be administered to confirm eligibility in protocol 2 but for protocol 1 the IDFAI and IPAQ will be collected for informative purposes and to help explain variability between participants. If eligibility is confirmed, participants will be enrolled and complete the study procedures. After eligibility is confirmed, all participants for both protocols will also complete the past-year physical activity questionnaire (PYPAQ) and protocol 2 participants will complete a running history questionnaire.
Following the surveys, height and weight will be measured then the dominant limb test and the preferred speed test will be performed. The dominant limb test determines whether the right or left lower limb is the dominant limb by observing which limb participants use to kick a ball. The preferred speed test involves the participant walking or running at or near their reported preferred speed (or 2.9 mph for walking and 4.5 mph for running if preferred speed is unknown). The speed will be blinded to the participant. The researcher will increase or decrease the speed in 0.5-1.0 mph increments until the participant identifies the same speed as their preferred speed three times.
Next, the participant will be prepared for data collection. Participants will be asked to change into form fitting clothing (provided by the laboratory, if needed) and the shoes they prefer to wear during exercise or physical activity (protocol 1), or combat boots provided by the laboratory (protocol 2). Next, reflective markers and the lab's research-grade inertial measurement units (IMUs) will be placed on anatomical landmarks of both feet, lower-legs, thighs, and pelvis, and the sensor-enabled ankle brace ("sXAB") will be secured on the dominant limb, if the first randomized condition is the brace condition. Participants will warm-up by walking on a treadmill before completing each of the brace conditions (brace and no-brace) to acclimate wearing the brace and/or the reflective markers and lab IMUs. Participants will then be asked to complete the movement tests specific to each protocol (protocol 1: standing balance, walking at preferred speed, walking at a standardized speed of 2.9 mph; protocol 2: standing balance, stairs, drop landing, walking at preferred speed, and running at preferred speed) while wearing the sXAB and without wearing the brace ("no brace" condition) as three-dimensional motion capture data, force plate data, IMU data, and data from the sXAB (if worn) are recorded. The order of the bracing conditions will be presented in a random order. The brace will be worn on the dominant limb. Within each brace condition, the standing balance test will be performed first then the remaining movements will be presented in a random order. After the first brace condition is complete, the participant will be prepared to complete the second brace condition then repeat the warm-up, standing balance test, and the movement tests.
Protocol 1 is expected to begin in late June 2025 and involve N=20 participants. After protocol 1 is complete, TayCo Brace, Inc. will make adjustments to the sXAB such as device placement on the brace, algorithms to output outcome measures, etc. that will be tested during protocol 2. Protocol 2 is expected to begin in September 2025 and will involve N=40 participants. Although device feasibility studies typically involve smaller sample sizes, this study includes a larger cohort (N = 60) to enable evaluation of sensor-derived metrics across a broad range of functional tasks. The study aims to determine whether gait and balance measures obtained from an ankle brace integrated with inertial measurement units are comparable to those from gold-standard laboratory tools, such as motion capture and research-grade IMUs.
The ankle brace used in this study is an FDA Class I exempt device. The version used includes integrated commercially available inertial sensors in which the investigators are evaluating their use with the brace against standard laboratory-based systems. The study does not involve a new intended use or clinical treatment evaluation.
Eligibility
Inclusion Criteria for both cohorts:
- Healthy adults: ages 18 - 40 years
- considered "healthy to exercise" as determined by the physical activity readiness questionnaire (PAR-Q)
Additional Inclusion Criteria specific to cohort 2 only:
- Classified as "moderate" or "high" activity level as defined by the scoring criteria of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire - Short Form (IPAQ)
- Comfortably fit into combat boots provided by the laboratory (Men's sizes 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and Women's sizes 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 will be purchased, and so participants with foot lengths of 22.54-29.27.8 cm are expected to fit in the boots provided).
Exclusion Criteria for both cohorts:
- Smoking tobacco on a regular basis
- Previous lower back or lower limb surgery (including the joints of the pelvis and lower limbs)
- Musculoskeletal injury sustained within the 12-weeks prior to enrollment . A musculoskeletal injury is defined as musculoskeletal pain causing a reduction or stoppage of normal physical activity for at least 3 days within a 7-day period, and have not returned to their normal physical activity and exercise without pain for at least the last 6-weeks.
- Pregnant (women only)
- Current or history of an unresolved musculoskeletal, neurological, cardiovascular, pulmonary/respiratory, metabolic, renal condition, disease, or problem.
- Torn anterior or posterior cruciate ligament (ACL or PCL).
- Any other disease or problems that may affect movement or the ability to exercise even at a low intensity.
Additional Exclusion Criteria specific to cohort 2 only:
- Identification of Functional Ankle Instability (IDFAI) score of <11.
- unable to comfortably perform the drop landing condition.
- Feet are too large or too small to fit comfortably in the combat boots provided.