Overview
About 26 000 patients are treated per year with radiotherapy for non-malignant diseases in the Czech Republic, majority of them with heel spur syndrome which prevalence ranges from 8-10% in the general population. Heel spur represents important socioeconomic as well as health care issue. Radiotherapy by orthovoltage X-ray belongs to standard conservative treatment methods with proven antiinflammatory effect. Nevertheless, with increasing incidence of cancer, it may be assumed that availability of radiotherapy service for heel spur patients will be further limited including limitations related to potential pandemic or other emergency situation. This represents upcoming unmet clinical need, where alternative approaches with dramatically abbreviated fractionation schedules are needed in order to keep availability as well as effectivity of heel spur (and other non-malignant disorders) radiotherapy.
The aim to presented single institutional prospective randomized open-lable clinical trial is to evaluate low dose radiotherapy delivered in single fraction manner in the treatment of heel spur syndrome.
The project aims to design a randomized trial that compared fractionated and single fraction radiotherapy (non-inferiority). Patients will be randomized into 6 groups according to the total dose, total of 966 patients will be enrolled. The primary objective is to compare Calcaneodynia sum score at 3 months after radiotherapy between fractionated vs. single fraction radiotherapy.
Description
Purpose/Objective The aim of this study is to optimize the fractionation schedules for radiotherapy in the treatment of heel spurs (HSS, plantar fasciitis) through a prospective randomized open-label trial conducted at Department of Radiation Oncology at Masaryk Memorial Cancer Institute Brno (MMCI). Low-dose external beam radiotherapy (LD-EBRT), known for its anti-inflammatory effect, offers effective pain relief for HSS patients. Currently, the standard LD-EBRT regimen consists of six fractions of 1 Gray (Gy) administered twice weekly, resulting in a total dose of 6 Gy. This study posits the hypothesis that very low total doses of orthovoltage radiotherapy, delivered in a single fraction, may provide pain relief comparable to that achieved with higher doses of fractionated radiotherapy. The primary goal of this research is to determine whether one-day irradiation (a single fraction) is non-inferior to fractionated radiotherapy over a three-month period in terms of pain relief for HSS patients. This study was supported by grant of the Ministry of Health of the Czech Republic AZV NU22-10-00479. All patients signed informed consent.
Material/Methods After completing the enrollment process and filling out the SF-36 questionnaire, as well as the Calcaneodynia score (CS) and visual analogue pain score (VAS) forms, patients (pts) meeting specific inclusion criteria (being over 40 years old, having a diagnosed painful unilateral plantar HSS for at least six months, and being suitable for HSS radiotherapy), and fulfilling the main exclusion criteria (having no prior history of radiotherapy for heel spur, no corticosteroid local application in the four weeks leading up to radiotherapy, no systemic rheumatic or collagen vascular diseases, lymphatic edema of the lower limb, or prior trauma and surgery on the ipsilateral foot), were randomized into six groups based on the total dose of radiotherapy. Patients in these groups received a total dose of 6 Gy in 4 fractions of 1.5 Gy twice weekly (arm A), a total dose of 3 Gy in 2 fractions of 1.5 Gy twice weekly (arm B), a single fraction of 0.5 Gy (arm C), a single fraction of 1.0 Gy (arm D), a single fraction of 1.5 Gy (arm E), and a single fraction of 2 Gy (arm F), respectively. The regimen in arm A (6 Gy in 4 fractions) is commonly used in MMCI and considered as the standard arm. In the event of inadequate pain relief, reirradiation was performed with a total dose of 6 Gy in 4 fractions of 1.5 Gy twice weekly after a waiting period of three months in any of the aforementioned groups.
Eligibility
All patients referred to medical attention for non-malignant radiotherapy at the Department
of Radiation oncology, Masaryk Memorial Cancer Institute (MMCI), will be screened for
eligibility, and if all inclusion/exclusion criteria are met, they will be invited to
participate in the present study.
Inclusion Criteria:
- 1) Patients aged over 40 years who have been diagnosed clinically and radiologically
to be suffering from a painful unilateral plantar heel spur for at least six months,
- 2) indication to heel spur radiotherapy,
- 3) 40 years or older patient, good performance status (Karnofsky index ≥ 70),
- 4) exclusion of other local diseases by the orthopaedic surgeon,
- 5) willingness of the patient to provide telephone or email contact to maintain follow
up.
Exclusion Criteria:
- 1) Prior radiotherapy of heel spur (even if prior radiotherapy was performed on the
contralateral heel spur because of possible bias given patient's expectations and
experiences related to previous radiotherapy,
- 2) corticosteroid local application during last 4 weeks prior to planned radiotherapy,
- 3) rheumatic or vascular diseases, lymphatic edema of lower limb,
- 4) former trauma or surgery of ipsilateral foot,
- 5) any systemic illness (collagen vascular diseases) or unstable medical condition
that might pose additional risk for performance of radiotherapy including
claustrophobia or jactation,
- 6) any other factors that, in the opinion of the site investigators, would interfere
with adherence to study requirements,
- 7) pregnancy or breastfeeding,
- 8) inability or unwillingness of subject to sign written informed consent.