Comparing a Novel Point-of-care Cytokine Biomarker Lateral Flow Test With Nucleic Acid Amplification Tests for Detection of Sexually Transmitted Infections and Bacterial Vaginosis

Overview

1. To evaluate the performance of a lateral flow POC test, namely the Genital InFlammation Test (GIFT), for identifying women with inflammatory STIs and BV, who are at higher risk of HIV infection and reproductive complications;
2. To evaluate how the GIFT device can be integrated in a feasible, acceptable, and cost-effective way into routine care.

Description

DIAGNOSTIC Study

Design

The study is a multicentre, multidisciplinary, cross sectional, prospective clinically based research project.

The first component is a diagnostic study which will enrol 225 women attending family planning services in each of the three study sites in South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Madagascar. Vaginal samples from the women will be applied to the GIFT device and results will be compared with the composite NAAT reference test for STIs and Nugent score test for BV to determine the performance of the device to detect STIs/BV. Women will attend only one study visit but will be recalled for treatment if required.

The second component to develop a feasible, acceptable and economically feasible STI/BV management algorithm which includes the use of the GIFT device to be integrated into national guidelines (hereafter referred to as the "integration study") is composed of four activities with different study designs: 1.User experiences and/or perceptions of the GIFT device involving qualitative focus group discussions and in-depth interviews, and a quantitative questionnaire for health care professionals; 2. Discrete choice experiment; 3 Development of a decision tree classification algorithm; 4. Economic evaluation of the defined management algorithms.

Study Sites:

1. Cape Town, South Africa; Desmond Tutu Health Foundation (DTHF) Masiphumelele
2. Harare, Zimbabwe; Chitungwiza Primary Health Care Clinics
3. Antananarivo, Madagascar; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Gynéco-Obstétrique de Befelatanana

Diagnostic Device:

The GIFT device is an immune-based lateral flow test for reproductive-aged, non-pregnant in resource-limited settings attending sexual reproductive health (family planning) clinics, community health centers, hospitals, and mobile clinics. The test involves the qualitative detection of genital inflammation caused by asymptomatic STIs and BV in self- or clinician-collected lateral vaginal wall swabs, with results available in less than 20 minutes.

Diagnostic Study Objectives:

Primary objectives To assess the sensitivity and specificity of the GIFT device at the point-of-care in non-pregnant sexually active women aged 18-35 years accessing family planning services in South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Madagascar.

Secondary objectives To assess the predictive values of the GIFT device at the point-of-care in non-pregnant sexually active women aged 18-35 years accessing family planning services in South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Madagascar; To assess the performance of the GIFT device at the point-of-care in non-pregnant sexually active women aged 18-35 years accessing family planning services in each of the countries; To assess the performance of the device versus syndromic management without any laboratory testing (standard of care in South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Madagascar); To determine the robustness of the device by comparing results read by clinicians with those read by laboratory professionals, and with the results obtained using an automated reader; To evaluate the accuracy of the GIFT device by comparing the GIFT device results with ELISA (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) results using previously validated concentration cut-offs as the gold standard, including validation of the GIFT cytokine concentration cut-offs for each cytokine biomarker.

Exploratory objectives Determine if other determinants (such as intermediate microbiota (Nugent 4-6), age, parity, sexual activity) improve the prediction of STI/BV status in women; To use 16S rRNA gene sequencing and vaginal bacteria specific quantitative NAATs to evaluate the proportion of cases of genital inflammation explained by vaginal dysbiosis that was not diagnosed as an STI or BV by NAATs or Nugent scoring; To explore the performance of the device in the presence of vaginal Candida spp colonisation.

INTEGRATION Study To evaluate how the GIFT device can be integrated in a feasible, acceptable, and cost-effective way into routine care (the "integration study"), four activities will be conducted: 1. User experiences and/or perceptions of the GIFT device; 2. Discrete choice experiment; 3 Development of a decision tree classification algorithm; 4. Economic evaluation of the defined management algorithms.

Objectives

Primary objective To evaluate how the GIFT device could be integrated into routine care.

Secondary objectives To qualitatively and quantitatively assess the user-experience, usability, and acceptability of the GIFT device at the point of care; To examine patient preferences for various STI management aspects (attributes) to inform the development of STI management algorithms that integrate the GIFT device; To generate algorithms that integrate the GIFT device to optimise case finding and STIs/vaginal infection management in women, using the complete dataset from the study; To determine the cost and budget impact of the identified screening or diagnostic algorithm with the GIFT device, and to model the costeffectiveness of different strategies of integration of GIFT into care.

Eligibility

Diagnostic Inclusion Criteria:

• 18-35 years old
• Willing and able to provide informed consent to participate in the study
• Self-reported to be sexually active
• Not pregnant (determined by pregnancy test)
• Accessing family planning service

Integration Inclusion Criteria:

For all: Willing and able to provide informed consent to participate in the study

User experiences/perceptions activity:

• Local or regional policy makers, programmers and other opinion leaders and decision makers
• Healthcare professionals at health facilities
• Women who are eligible for the diagnostic study (including pregnant and menstruating women), but who are not part of the diagnostic study
• 18-35 years old
• Willing and able to provide informed consent to participate in the study
• Self-reported to be sexually active
• Accessing family planning service diagnostic study

Discrete choice experiments:

• Women who are eligible for the diagnostic study (including pregnant and menstruating women), who are either part of, or not part of, the diagnostic study
• 18-35 years old
• Self-reported to be sexually active
• Accessing family planning service diagnostic study

Decision tree classification algorithm:

• Data from diagnostic study participants

Economic evaluation:

• Healthcare professionals at health facilities involved in GIFT device implementation able to complete timesheets

Diagnostic Exclusion Criteria:

• <18 years or >35 years
• Refusal by a participant to participate in the study
• Treatment for any STI/BV in the past 30 days
• Pregnancy
• Enrolled in a study which does not allow co-enrolment in other studies

Integration Exclusion Criteria:

For all: Not willing or able to provide informed consent to participate in the study

User experiences/perceptions activity:

• Non-relevant policy makers
• Healthcare professionals at health facilities not included in diagnostic study

Women who are:

• Part of the diagnostic study
• <18 years or >35 years
• Treated for any STI/BV in the past 30 days
• Pregnant
• Enrolled in a study which does not allow co-enrolment in other studies

Discrete choice experiments:

Women who are:

• <18 years or >35 years
• Treated for any STI/BV in the past 30 days
• Pregnant
• Enrolled in a study which does not allow co-enrolment in other studies

Decision tree classification algorithm:

• Participants for whom there are no diagnostic study data

Economic evaluation:

• Healthcare professionals not at study sites, not involved in GIFT device implementation, and/or not able to complete timesheets